
This is taken from a conversation I had on a recent plane trip:
I was on a twelve hour flight from New York JFK to home, when from the end of the aisle someone calls out my name. It’s Jessica. Our face lit up, a skilled airplane runner, she quickly stumbles over bags, squeezes through the queued crowd and turns to give me a hug.
“How you been?”
“Great I guess”
I didn’t see her since last winter. She looks tired, with her high cheek bones dropping low and dark shadows settling under her glistening eyes. Yet she smiles nonetheless, eagerly asking questions of how I’ve been doing and what she’s been up to. I ask her if she’s happy at Wesleyan, she beams.
“I love it. I really do, I was scared when I made my choice but I think I made the right one.”
“Scared?”
“You know, I am scared of choices. Especially the ones that I know will change who I am.”
“But making choices is the only thing that allows us to have a decent say of where we end up”
“Exactly, I am a firm believer that we make our own destiny, that’s why choices scare me the most”
“What if the choices I am making are all but the wrong ones? It’s terrifying.”
“Yea but come on, there are no wrong choices.”
“You’re a prick.”
“Everybody makes choices, As you said, we choose who we are, we choose where we go. Its an inevitable process.”
But she is adamant. “Have you heard of the ‘Learnt Helplessness Experiment’? They put two groups of dogs in cages and subjected them to pain through electric shocks. Group one’s cage had levers the dogs could press to cut off the electricity, but for the latter, the dogs had no mechanism to independently stop the shocks. So the dogs in the lever-less cage soon learned they could not end the shocks regardless of how hard they tried; They barked, they bit the bars, hopelessly attempted to run, but they could not escape. Eventually, when the cages were lifted, allowing both groups to escape, the dogs in group one chose to move out of the cage. The dogs in group two did not move. They chose to endure the shocks quietly. They had learnt helplessness, they lost hope in choices, they now believed everything was exogenous.”
She takes a sip of the complementary water, before staring at me,
“Many of us, me and you included, come from places we know our choices matter. We are privileged in the way that we can make our choices count. Many don’t, for many the outside factors play bigger roles in their lives.”
“That’s why choices scare me, they are a burden that becomes heavier the more you believe in them.”
I wasn’t sure if I fully agreed. But this made me uncomfortable
Also, poor dogs. -142